Seriously tasty, flavorful and tender! But there are so many “nose wrinkles” that happen when you mention you are serving lamb. With this recipe and your trusty Traeger grill, you’ll wow your dinner guests with this fall feast as summer comes to a close.
This bone-in whole lamb leg will make a great centerpiece for one last dinner outdoors (or inside if the rains have come to your area already) and will leave you with great leftovers for sandwiches and salads all week long. An average bone-in lamb leg is a cut from the upper haunches of the lamb and will weigh around 5 to 7 pounds. We’re cooking one today that is just over 5lb.
If you are buying from a reputable butcher, ask them for a market-weight lamb (not a baby and not an old lamb-mutton). And ask them to trim the outer layer of fat. Trimming the fat is the number one key to cooking a flavorful but not strong and “gamy” tasting lamb. Don’t trim too much though, as the fat will render during cooking and insulate the meat, keeping it nice and tender.
This bone-in whole lamb leg will make a great centerpiece for one last dinner outdoors (or inside if the rains have come to your area already) and will leave you with great leftovers for sandwiches and salads all week long. An average bone-in lamb leg is a cut from the upper haunches of the lamb and will weigh around 5 to 7 pounds. We’re cooking one today that is just over 5lb.
If you are buying from a reputable butcher, ask them for a market-weight lamb (not a baby and not an old lamb-mutton). And ask them to trim the outer layer of fat. Trimming the fat is the number one key to cooking a flavorful but not strong and “gamy” tasting lamb. Don’t trim too much though, as the fat will render during cooking and insulate the meat, keeping it nice and tender.
Rub Ingredients
1 Tbsp mesquite spice blend (can substitute smoked paprika) This mesquite blend from Natural Grocers contains garlic, onion, tomato, sugar, cayenne, cumin seed, sage, black pepper, celery seed, cinnamon, paprika, marjoram, sea salt 1/3 cup ground chipotle pepper 1 Tsp ground mustard 1/3 Cup Oregano 1 Tbsp pink salt 1 Tbsp cumin 2 Tbsp ground fennel seed 1 Lemon zestedFor The Coating
3 Tbsp Extra virgin olive oil 1 Tsp of hot sauce (I use Truff hot sauce) 1 Tsp balsamic vinegarFor The Spritz
1 Cup apple cider vinegar 3 Tbsp hot sauce (I use Truff hot sauce) 1 Tbsp balsamic vinegar reductionSteps
1. Add Traeger Apple Wood pellets2. Preheat at 185 degrees
3. Ingredients and setup
4. Coat with oil mixture
5. Rub with the spice blend
6. Smoke for 2 hours at 185
7. Spritz lamb on all sides generously
8. Cover with foil
9. Raise grill temp to 285
10. Back on the grill for up to 4hrs or until internal temp is 165 degrees (well done virtually no pink).
[ux_video url="https://vimeo.com/466006972"]
6. Smoke for 2 hours at 185
7. Spritz lamb on all sides generously
8. Cover with foil
9. Raise grill temp to 285
10. Back on the grill for up to 4hrs or until internal temp is 165 degrees (well done virtually no pink).
NOTE: if you want a medium-rare roast with pink inside, cook to 130 degrees and medium 135 to 140 degrees.11. Unwrap and let rest for 15 minutes 12. Slice and serve
[ux_video url="https://vimeo.com/466006972"]
We would love to see your Traeger Recipes, use #mywilcolife on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram and tag Wilco Stores.
Orders
Services
About
Your Wilco Store
Store Hours
Monday to Saturday:
8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
Sunday: 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Need Help?
For questions or help with online orders call: (888) 78-WILCO
Limited to stock on hand. Some items may vary from photos. Because of store size limitations or geography, some items featured may not be available in all stores but will be made available by special order during sale periods at advertised prices. All sale prices listed as “dollars off” or “% off” are discounted from our regular posted shelf price, not from discounts given with specialty, bulk or pallet pricing. Reseller and Drop-shippers must contact us for pre-approval to place orders with the intent to re-distribute.
© 2025, Wilco Farm Store